Skip to content

The Book I Wasn’t Ready to Write

An essay about the origin story of Finding Surf—and the years it took to find my way into writing it. Published on Brevity Blog.

Sometimes an idea comes long before you’re ready.

To confront a fear of being thrown around in breaking waves, I surfed my first wave on my 40th birthday. I soon began to recognize how much surfing was teaching me about how I wanted to meet life. And how often I got it wrong!

I wanted to share my experiences in a way that might spark others—surfers and non-surfers—to think differently about their own lives. It took me nine years to figure out how.

I began keeping a journal. A few details about each surf session. Occasionally I’d have a thought, or something would happen that I’d want to explore. Writing is the easiest way for me to do that.

It was around that time that I discovered Jaimal Yogis’s spiritual memoir Saltwater Buddha. His story spoke to me. I especially like how he weaves the Buddhist principles he grew up with into his experiences. Inspired, I set out to turn my own essays into a book. As I researched further, I found another book that looked like the one I was going to write. It even had the same title! Deflated, I lost my inspiration.

But the idea wouldn’t leave me alone. I kept surfing, and kept writing, all while finding reasons not to write the book. Every so often, it would nudge me. In 2017, I hammered out what I now call my stream-of-consciousness draft. A beautiful mess. I’d even left a big fat placeholder that said something like, “And this section will do xyz.”

I found a developmental editor, Stuart Horwitz, who was willing to read it. I connected with his critique style immediately. He approached my unruly manuscript almost exactly the way I would approach reviewing a business plan.

First, some encouragement. Then the problem. A book can only be about one thing. He saw two possible themes, perhaps even a third. I needed to choose.

His favorite theme was what I’d intended the book to be. Not a story about a woman learning to surf and having adventures, but surfing as a metaphor for everything.

Then he got to the section I’d left as a placeholder. “In short, I think this is the book,” he wrote.

Why hadn’t I written it? Had I run out of steam getting there? He ended his critique by reassuring me that I had the capacity to write the book. I just needed to choose an approach and follow it through.

I sat with all his feedback. Agreed with it. But still couldn’t figure out how to execute my vision. I put the manuscript away. Got busy working on other things I cared deeply about. Surfing became an even larger part of my life. And every once in a while, the book idea poked at me again.

And then, something happened. Suddenly, the book I’d spent eight years not knowing how to write was something I felt I had to write. I tell that story in the book, but that’s not the point.

This kind of shift can happen to any of us for all kinds of reasons. We finally have the time to focus. An injury or illness interrupts our usual routine. Something challenging happens in our lives, and we need somewhere positive to put our creative energy. Or maybe reading about someone finally completing a book after five, ten, maybe even forty years is inspiration enough to return to an idea that won’t leave them alone.

I wrote a draft in less than thirty days. I did not sign up for one of those “write a book in thirty days” programs. I just started writing and couldn’t stop. The perfectionist in me didn’t even slow down to fix things along the way. I wasn’t worrying about how rough it was, whether it was any good, whether it would ever see the light of day. It just came out. One big barf.

On New Year’s Eve, 2025, I emailed Stuart. I reminded him that he’d critiqued my brain dump eight years earlier and asked whether he was still doing the same work. I understood it was a holiday—I wasn’t expecting an immediate response—but he replied quickly. He’s still at it. And he was willing to dive back into the water with me.

For years, I let myself believe that everything to be said about surfing had already been said. Fear, presence, letting go of control, waves, wipeouts. All the obvious life metaphors. But I realize I still enjoy reading other people’s stories. Each is unique to the person who lived it, and I almost always find something that inspires me. The book I found all those years ago wasn’t my book after all. Neither were any of the essays, talks, or books I’ve encountered since.

That first manuscript in 2017 wasn’t my book either. It was a lump of clay I didn’t yet know how to mold. All these years later, it’s finally taking shape. Not quite ready for the kiln, but getting there.